Maslow and Tutu on personhood

Abraham Maslow 2New York in the 1920s was a tough place to grow up, especially if you were the son of Jewish émigrés from Russia. Amidst poverty, anti-Semitism and inter-ethnic violence, the young Abraham Maslow struggled to come to terms with his life. Perhaps he was depressed. Certainly he was a sensitive soul. We would not be surprised if he sought a strong inner world of the mind when the outer world amongst other people was harsh.

Maslow became an academic psychologist. He was much taken up with the concept of self-actualisation as the ultimate goal of the person. For Maslow, this meant achieving a high degree of understanding and moral character. He is most well known for putting this goal on top of his hierarchy of needs, which is widely referenced in all sorts of academic and popular discussions.

maslow

Maslow’s hierarchy places habitual physical needs at the base of a pyramid. The fulfilment of these basic requirements of life lead us to want to exercise a greater control over what provides these needs. We are then sufficiently secure to raise families and enjoy the pleasures of love and friendship. These in turn give rise to our capacity to grow in confidence and achieve goals according to our abilities. At the top of the pyramid, we are able to pursue the god-like characteristics implicit in the notion of self-actualisation. The hierarchy assumes a model of primacy for the individual; that resources and relationships are there to feed the emergence of the autonomous and empowered individual.

Johannesburg society in the 1940s was more carefully structured than New York in the 1920’s. The divides boiled down to one simple factor: the colour of your skin. Moving there at the age of twelve, Desmond Tutu faced the relentless prejudice against his personhood. Denied many of the most basic privileges, he was unlikely to rise through a hierarchy of needs to reach the self-actualisation envisaged my Maslow. And, indeed, he came to a rather different conclusion as a result of his circumstances.

desmond-tutu-birthday-007Tutu was part of a people against whom society had turned with increasing vehemence. He drew from his own language a word that supported a movement: Ubuntu. In confronting apartheid and in building the ‘rainbow nation’, Tutu popularised an approach to personhood based around this word: ‘Ubuntu recognizes the interconnectedness of life. My humanity is bound up with your humanity’.

Under the philosophy of apartheid, one person’s personhood was considered inferior to another’s. Unless people together welcomed their equal and common humanity, it would be impossible for the individual to achieve his or her full potential.

Maslow’s hierarchy offers some informative signposts amidst the complex dynamic world in which we live. But these are no more than signposts. We cannot conceive of the isolated individual as a single unit. The person is very much caught up in her relationships and in her socio-economic environment. Tutu’s Ubuntu reminds us that the individual is very much a participant with others in forming collective identity and culture. We are recognised and named by the wider community, and we are offered rights, responsibilities, beliefs and practices that shape so much of what we become.

Desmond Tutu’s book is inspiring:

5 thoughts on “Maslow and Tutu on personhood

  1. I really like Tutu’s concept of Ubuntu. Interestingly, during my current course of Autogenic Training, Maslow’s hierarchy was referred to very early on. And an addition was made to each of the domains – ‘nurturing, love and care needs’ ( Gordon, 1996 and Sunderland, 2006) – as needs necessary across them all.

    Like

  2. Dear All, Physiological needs as depicted by Maslow are in dearth/poor condition in intervened region of Kunri Christian Hospital district umerkot sindh Pakistan . Throughout the world every day 21000 people die because of hunger and hunger related issues according to UN. In district umerkot 50% of population lives below poverty line. In prevailing circumstances how one could reach at self actulaization stage ?. What remedial/preventive measures should be adopted to bring the masses out from the vicious cycle of poverty?
    An open ended two question to the stakeholders!
    Thanks, Naveed Adminstrator KCH Email:kunri.hospital@yahoo.com

    Like

  3. As a medical student in Bristol UK I shared a flat with Michael who was a student of theology. We often talked about “being me and being us” and the issues around self actualization. One day Michael returned to the flat following what he felt was his “Eureka” moment when his lecturer had introduced the ideas of Martin Buber which he summed up as “I come into existence over against the THOU or I come into existence over against you” . I too felt this was a great way of thinking about being me and being us . In my doctoring work patients often feel very alone and isolated – abandoned even – I have found that sharing myself with patients and being alongside people in their loneliness has very often been felt by patients to have been vital in their recovery so they have told me often years later. Maybe others can post more about Martin Buber and his views ?

    Like

  4. We can also apply the Maslow’s hierarchy at different levels. Our philosophy of work should be therefore “team work” when team members from different disciplines and different cultures complement each other and reach set targets together! A dream perhaps but this is the only way to improve the health conditions of individuals and communities!

    Like

  5. I also think it is interesting that of course, Bp. Tutu did become ‘self-actualized’, in Maslow’s terminology. He is one of the most well-known and influential leaders in the world today. And I think this shows not only your excellent point, Paul, but also that even the logic of the ‘needs hierarchy’ – physical needs, then relationships, then higher goals, are good to think about in a general sense, but there is certainly no evidence that they apply to every person in every situation. Thank you for this!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s